Almost every personal injury case settles before trial, which leads a lot of people to assume trial experience is a nice-to-have rather than something that actually affects their case. That assumption gets it backwards.
Why Trial Experience Still Matters Even for a Case That Settles
Yes, trial experience matters even if your case ultimately settles, because insurance companies adjust their offers based on whether they believe your attorney will actually litigate. California’s offer-to-compromise statute, Code of Civil Procedure Section 998, gives trial-ready attorneys concrete financial leverage in negotiations that a settlement-focused firm generally can’t use effectively. The way to tell the difference isn’t a firm’s marketing, it’s asking specific questions about actual verdicts.
Why Trial Experience Matters Even If Your Case Never Goes to Trial
Insurance companies don’t pay full value simply because someone was genuinely hurt. Adjusters evaluate claims partly based on the injury and partly based on the attorney handling it, specifically, whether that attorney will actually invest in depositions, expert witnesses, and court filings, or whether they’re known for settling quickly regardless of case value. A firm that handles a high volume of claims and resolves nearly all of them through early settlement, sometimes called a “settlement mill,” tends to receive lower initial offers precisely because insurers know litigation isn’t a credible threat. A firm with a genuine track record of taking cases to verdict changes that calculation before negotiations even begin.
The risk becomes concrete when a case genuinely doesn’t settle for a fair amount and actually needs to go to trial. A firm built around fast resolutions often hasn’t invested in the depositions, expert retention, and evidentiary groundwork a trial actually requires, since that work only pays off if the case proceeds that far. When that happens, some firms refer the case out to trial counsel at the last minute, handing off a case that wasn’t built with a courtroom in mind and giving the new attorney little time to prepare properly. A firm that builds every case as if it might go to trial, even the ones that ultimately settle, doesn’t face that scramble, because the groundwork was already there from the start.
The Legal Mechanism Behind the Leverage: California's Offer-to-Compromise Statute
California Code of Civil Procedure Section 998 gives trial readiness real, quantifiable teeth. A party can make a formal settlement offer at least ten days before trial, and if the other side rejects it and then fails to do better at the actual trial, real financial consequences follow. A plaintiff who rejects a defendant’s reasonable Section 998 offer and then recovers less at trial can be ordered to pay the defendant’s litigation costs, including expert witness fees, incurred from the date of the offer forward. A defendant who rejects a plaintiff’s reasonable offer and then loses for more at trial can face even steeper consequences, including prejudgment interest on the judgment. This mechanism only works as leverage if the other side actually believes the case could go to trial. An attorney who has never tried a case, or who is known for settling regardless of the offer, can’t credibly use Section 998 to pressure a better outcome, because the insurer knows the threat behind it is empty.
|
Wondering If Your Settlement Offer Reflects Your Case’s Real Value? It might not, if the insurer doesn’t think you’ll go to trial. Call DKB Lawyers at (949) 776-2856. |
How to Actually Verify an Attorney's Trial Experience
Marketing language claiming decades of “combined experience” or a firm-wide reputation for aggressive representation doesn’t tell you much about whether the specific attorney handling your case has personally tried a case to verdict. It’s worth asking directly how many cases that attorney, not the firm as a whole, has taken to trial, and what the outcomes were. A firm that answers this question with specifics, including cases it didn’t win, is generally more credible than one that redirects toward how quickly it resolves claims. It’s also worth noticing whether a firm’s own marketing emphasizes speed and convenience over results, since that emphasis can itself be a signal about how the firm actually operates when an insurer refuses to offer a fair amount.
|
Not Sure If Your Current Lawyer Is Actually Trial-Ready? It’s worth a second opinion before you settle. Call DKB Lawyers at (949) 776-2856 for a free consultation. |
Find an Injury Lawyer Who's Actually Prepared to Go to Trial
The strength of your settlement offer often depends less on your injuries alone and more on whether the insurer believes your attorney is actually prepared to go to trial. DKB Lawyers was founded by attorneys who spent years on the other side representing insurance companies, and that experience shapes how we build every case from the start.
|
Call (949) 776-2856 for a Free Consultation. No fee unless we win your case. |