Jump to
A defective product claim in California starts from an unusually favorable position for an injured consumer: strict liability, meaning you generally don’t have to prove a manufacturer was careless, only that the product was defective and that defect caused your personal injury. Manufacturers aren’t defenseless either, and knowing what their narrow defenses actually cover, and don’t, matters just as much as knowing your own burden of proof.
What You Need to Prove, and the Defenses Manufacturers Raise
A California product liability claim generally requires showing a defendant designed, made, or sold the product, that it was defective, that you used it as intended, and that the defect caused your injury. Manufacturers can raise specific defenses in response, including a narrow “common knowledge” defense for products that are inherently unsafe by nature, like alcohol or sugar, and a separate “sophisticated user” defense that can reduce a manufacturer’s duty to warn users who already understand a product’s risks. Neither defense applies as broadly as manufacturers sometimes argue.
The Four Elements of a California Product Liability Claim
To hold a manufacturer, distributor, or seller liable for a defective product in California, you generally need to establish four things: that the defendant designed, manufactured, or sold the product, that it was defective or unreasonably dangerous, that you were using it as intended or in a reasonably foreseeable way, and that the defect actually caused your injury. Because California applies strict liability to defective products, you don’t need to prove the defendant was negligent, a meaningfully lower bar than an ordinary negligence claim, though every element still requires real evidence to establish.
That lower bar on the plaintiff’s side is exactly why California law gives manufacturers a handful of specific, narrow defenses to push back with, rather than leaving them exposed to liability any time a product causes harm. Two of those defenses come up often enough, and get misunderstood often enough, that they’re worth understanding on their own terms.
Hurt by a Defective Product? Understanding the defenses a manufacturer might raise matters just as much as proving your own case. Call DKB Lawyers at (949) 535-1341.
The "Common Knowledge" Defense for Inherently Unsafe Products
California Civil Code Section 1714.45 gives manufacturers and sellers a narrow defense for a specific category of products: those that are inherently unsafe by their very nature and whose danger is common knowledge to the ordinary consumer. The statute names a short list of examples directly, including sugar, castor oil, alcohol, and butter, products that carry well-understood risks simply by being what they are, not because something went wrong in how they were made. To use this defense, a manufacturer has to show both that the product is genuinely inherently unsafe and that its danger is known to ordinary consumers with the kind of common knowledge shared across the community, not some obscure or newly discovered risk.
This defense is considerably narrower than it’s sometimes made out to be. It doesn’t apply at all to a manufacturing defect claim, meaning a defective batch or unit that departed from the product’s intended design isn’t protected just because the general product category is inherently risky. It also doesn’t apply to a breach of express warranty claim, and tobacco manufacturers specifically are excluded from using it at all, though retailers and distributors of tobacco products can still raise it. In practice, this defense protects a manufacturer from being sued simply for making a product that’s risky by its nature and well understood to be so, not from being sued over something that actually went wrong in making or marketing it.
Told Your Injury Doesn’t Count Because the Product Is “Naturally” Risky? That defense has real limits. Call DKB Lawyers at (949) 535-1341 for a free consultation.
When a User's Own Expertise Reduces a Manufacturer's Duty to Warn
A separate defense applies to a different kind of case: one involving a failure to warn rather than a design or manufacturing defect. The California Supreme Court adopted the “sophisticated user” defense in Johnson v. American Standard, Inc., holding that a manufacturer isn’t liable for failing to warn a sophisticated user of a risk that user already knew, or reasonably should have known, about. The standard is objective, based on what a class of similarly trained or experienced users would generally be expected to know at the time, not on what any one individual plaintiff happened to actually know.
The court’s reasoning was practical: warning a professional about a danger that’s already standard knowledge in their field doesn’t meaningfully improve safety, and treating every user as if they need the same baseline warnings as a first-time consumer can dilute the effectiveness of warnings generally. This defense applies to both strict liability and negligence-based failure-to-warn claims, but it’s specific to the failure-to-warn theory; it doesn’t extend to a claim that the product itself was defectively designed or manufactured, where a user’s expertise generally isn’t a defense at all.
Talk to an Orange County Product Liability Lawyer
Whether a manufacturer is raising a common knowledge defense, a sophisticated user defense, or another argument entirely, DKB Lawyers helps injured consumers throughout Orange County understand where these defenses actually apply, and where they don’t.
Call (949) 535-1341 for a Free Consultation. No fee unless we win your case.













